Christians, like the Jews, came to think ofNero asan evil apocalyptic figure, the one who had supposedly killed Peter and Paul and was the first persecutor of the Christians. The people of Argos took this as a sign and chose Danaus as their king. 5. And for him the issue was settled and there is no record that he ever persecuted the Christians again. Another contemporary, Pliny, shared the same negative view of Christians. In retribution the twins, tie Dirce to the horns of a bull and guide it, dragging her to a painful death. Even if it was for guilty persons who deserved to suffer extreme and exemplary public punishments, there arose a feeling of pity because it was not for the public good but to satisfy one mans savagery that they were being liquidated. Again, there is no connection with Nero or with the Fire. Shaw, a classicist, demonstrates a critical approachthat is all too seldom encountered among ancient historians and theologians who refuse to face the questionable quality of their primarysources. [26] It can be observed that the names Armoaste and Danaes (Danais), was an addition to complete the list while Scea (Scaea) and Autonomes (Automate) which was obviously borrowed from Apollodorus' accounts were also added. The phrase a type of men of a new and evil superstitio, in Shaws assessment, reads very much like Suetoniuss own commentary drawing upon what was known of Christians in his day, in the early second century. ", "Neil, this is actually rather useful. For if I say to you: I recognise in that dream,such and such a myth; or in that emotion about my father, that folk-tale; or the atmosphere of that memory is the same as an English ballad-then you smile, you are satisfied. This excerpt from the Letter of Clement, written around 95 AD, is important historical evidence of the martyrdom of Peter and Paul in Rome after Pauls journey to Spain. The gaps are striking lacunae in the knowledge of a senator from Italy, frequently resident in or near the imperial capital, who was well informed on these matters, And this evidence, focusing its special emphasis on the Christians and the execution of their leader under Pontius Pilatus in the reign of Tiberius, appears to have come to his attention after he wrote the, Despite the historians different agenda in the. ", "For an excellent example of generally high-quality scholarship by someone who isnt a biblical studies professor, see Neil Godfreys work posted on the website vridar.org. I have just sent this letter to the New York Review of books. . The Roman church needs reminding, too. Dirke was probably the same as the nymphe Derketis. Not available publicly on our website or anywhere else exclusively for our confirmed subscribers! Despite the historians different agenda in the Histories, that silence, I would argue, suggests that a different kind of information had come to the historians attention in the years after he wrote the Histories. certain women who were spectacularly executed, dressed up as Danaids and Dircae. Both Tacitus and Suetonius actually refer to Chrestiani, not Christiani a detail indicating that this was the name by which they were commonly known in the early second century. As such he was bound, by a kind of natural enmity, to have been the first to persecute the Christians; as Sulpicius puts it, because vice is always the enemy of the good.[68] The second is the political interest of the Christians in representing themselves as Neros victims, in order to win the favour and protection of his successors on that account. Best, Emanuel", "These reviews of yours are so bloody weird! In 1910,[41] the Hungarian poet Mihly Babits published his poem The Danaids, translated into English by Peter Zollman[42] and Istvn Ttfalusi.[43]. The Myth of the Neronian Persecution. papyrus 115 says 616 which i feel was referring to Nero . As far as you are concerned, I've gone beyond the childish, I've transmuted it and saved it, by embodying it in myth. Doris Lessing, I like the probability of the impossible." Do you have a question about Greece and the Greek islands? Thus Shaws contention, as Bowersock puts it, that Tacituss version of the fire derives from a fiction, Christian or otherwise, that was devised and disseminated at some point between 64 and the time when he was writing, more than five decades later, fails to take into account the silence of three long centuries (including in all Roman historians as well). Cassius Dio(ca 155-235 C.E.) I do need to touch on the two women Clement lists, "the Danaids and Dircae." According to the footnote in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later. Did the following really happen? I also have a rough draft of what will be the Rebuilding the Foundations book. Christian Interpolation in Josephus Antiquitates Judaicae (c. 94 C.E.). Best, John", John Moles, September 2011 (personal email), "I always enjoy reading Neils blog because I think that he is careful, thorough, intellectually fair, and honest. Jones) (Greek travelogue C2nd A.D.) : Aelian, Historical Miscellany 12. Five Reasons Why Mythicism is Disappointing, Where Morality Comes From a Rawlsian view, As for Near Death Experiences, I ask myself what is more likely: that a person really did in some sense, There are tonnes of things in the ot that draw from ancient near East beliefs, further Myth made fact a, Dear Austendw, Darshans essay is fascinating, and shows in my opinion how much Leviticus sacrificial and purity laws are at, Hi Neil As you may remember, I have not in the past been a fan of Russell Gmirkins theory that, I wish there was an edit button: These bittersweet messages seem, to me, to be more of a sigh of, The problem of course is that the serpents advice is perfectly reasonable and indeed wise. Clement cites examples drawn both from the Bible and from his own time to illustrate the danger of desintegration facing Corinths Christian community. 6:3 Jealousy hath estranged wives from their husbands and changed the saying of our father Adam, This now is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh. 33:11]; adding, moreover, this gracious declaration, 'Repent, O house of Israel, of your iniquity'" [Ezek. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. Hence the work was almost unknown throughout the Middle Ages, and no one was aware of the reference in it to a Roman persecution of the Christians. the pagan writer Tacitus testifies to these evernt in his Annales (15, 44) as does Clement, bishop of Rome, in his letter to the Corinthians (chapters 5-7). To begin with, there is no evidence that Christians were crucified as a penalty for their faith. Please carry on. He offers the suggestion that Chrestus might be one of the freedmen advisers to the emperor Claudius, using as analogy the anti-semitic Helicon, counselor to Gaius Caligula. Howbeit, one day her bonds were loosed of themselves, and unknown to her keepers she came to her sons cottage, begging that they would take her in. But Lycus married Dirce. God proved for over a thousand years of working with Israel that we humans are prone neither to repentance doing good. Its an interesting hypothesis. This is quite improbable. ", "Ive even been cited by atheists with approval (which I really dont know how to take, so thanks, I think, but Im not sure,Vrider(even though I feel like I need to take a shower now)). St. Clement was the bishop of Rome and third in succession from St. Peter. The trope of the jealous spouse delating his wife to Roman authorities in the city of Rome is also found in the writings of Justin Martyr who was probably writing in the mid-second century. Shaws points here are significant. Later sources such as the writing of Sulpicius Severus are useless for our enquiry because they all depend on Tacitus. [Many ingenious conjectures might be cited; but see Jacobson's valuable note, Patres Apostol., . ", Pseudo-Hyginus, Fabulae 7 (trans. 67 In his De lAuthenticity des Histoires et des Annales de Tacite, Hochart points out that, whereas the Life of St. Martin and the Dialogues of Sulpicius were found in many libraries, there was only one manuscript of Sulpicius Severuss Chronicle, probably of the eleventh century, which is now in the Vatican. The absence is doubly striking since it was precisely a fire at Nicomedia (two of them, in fact) that caused Galerius and Diocletian to turn on the Christians in the Great Persecution of 303 C.E. Where to stay? Subsequently, the author provides his interpretation of the allegoric names Danads suggesting that it was given to Christian women who, for religious reasons, refused or reduced sexual relations with their pagan husbands a motif quite frequently met in ancient Christian literature. . Modern historians have tended to defend Tacitus reliability in general, superior to so many others in his ancient field, and Prof. Shaws desire to lean toward that direction produces the one notable flaw in his case. 8:3). . For we are struggling on the same arena, and the same conflict is assigned to both of us. To get rid of the rumour, Nero found and provided the defendants, and he afflicted with the most refined punishments those persons whom, hated for their shameful acts, the common people were accustomed to call Chrestiani. Lynceus killed Danaus as revenge for the death of his brothers and he and Hypermnestra started the Danaid Dynasty of rulers in Argos. Owing to envy, Paul also obtained the reward of patient endurance, after being seven times thrown into captivity, compelled to flee, and stoned. Per Porter, Stanley E.; Pearson, Brook W.R. (2000). Some authors offer the one version, some the other. | Privacy Policy The more I read your stuff (and I still do, of course), the more I realize how much we all owe you. The prospect of a Christian interpolation in Tacitus, The Ambiguity of the Serpent: Greek versus Biblical, The Biblical Cain and his Greek Counterparts, Garden of Eden : Mesopotamian Perspectives, http://dspace.nwu.ac.za/handle/10394/14213, Rome Burning and the Christians: A New Study Vridar, https://earlywritings.com/forum/viewtopic.php?p=145080#p145080, Book of Revelation Annotated List of Posts, Daniel Gullottas Review of Richard Carriers, Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son (Levenson), Ending of the Gospel of Mark (16:8) ANNOTATED INDEX, Genre of Gospels, Acts and OT Primary History: INDEX, Historical Methods (with reference to the study of Christian Origins/Historicity of Jesus), Jesus: a Saviour Just Like the Kings and Gods of Egypt and Babylon, Inside the Pentecostal Christians Mind #1, The Garden of Eden [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus-Critias 7a], The Second Creation Story in Genesis [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 6], Sovereign Citizens, ISIS and Moonies the common thread that binds them all, When God Created Humans, then Retired: Genesis 1 as Science [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 5c], The Late Origins of Judaism The Archaeological Evidence, In Six Days: Genesis 1 as Science [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 5b], In the Beginning: Genesis 1 as Science [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 5a], Genesis 1 as Philosophy [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 4], Why Genesis 1-3 is Different from Other Myths [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 3b], Genesis = Science + Myth + Theology [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 3a], Genesis 1 Amazing Unique [Biblical Creation Accounts/Platos Timaeus 2], Charbonnel: Jesus Christ sublime figure de papier, Shawaccepts that Tacitus was a relatively reliable historian not given to outright invention. In the Metamorphoses,[1] Ovid refers to them as the Belides after their grandfather Belus. After preaching both in the east and west, he gained the illustrious reputation due to his faith, having taught righteousness to the whole world, and come to the extreme limit of the west, and suffered martyrdom under the prefects. What seems to make the idea so compelling and impossible to dismiss is that it is based on a high quality historical source of apparently unimpeachable fidelity, the, Not by any human resources, not by the benefactions of the emperor, and not by any placating of the gods did. | Contact Us Shawnotes that from time to time detailed arguments do appear to claim the following passage is a later interpolation in whole or in part. Through envy and jealousy, the greatest and most righteous pillars [of the Church] have been persecuted and put to death. Thus was he removed from the world. 1 Clem. Its always gratifying when a reader zeroes in on exactly those aspects I thought were most interesting and most central to my argument. These were the measures devised by human planning [i.e. . Finally a clever forger (Poggio?) Wilsons TLS (11 December) review of J.D. Neil is the author of this post. However, Shaw stresses the importance of recognising the passage is the only source for the involvement of Christians with the fire and their persecution in its aftermath.. Around the year 95 AD, a letter was written by the Church of Rome to the Church at Corinth that is attributed to Saint Clement. (Later still Jewish mythology concocted scenarios where Nero converted to Judaism and kept divine vengeance at bay.) It is most likely that Tacitus and Pliny exchanged information on these Christians who, as Pliny records, appeared to bebecoming a noticeable social nuisance. Anyone interested in becoming a professional umpire and becoming eligible to work in the minor leagues must attend one of the two umpire schools sanctioned by Major League Baseball. Parts came from written records about the fire, and oral recollections; others came from contemporary cognizance of imperial administrators about such an identifiable and threatening group, and still others were further contemporary sources that linked the Christians with Nero. The expressions of Sulpicius agree, in part, almost word for word with those of Tacitus. A lot was cast among the sons of Aegyptus to decide which of the Danaids each should marry except for those daughters born to Memphis who were joined by their namesakes, the sons of Tyria. ", "By the way, my thanks to Neil for an ongoing superb job of exposing Jims review for what it is: a farcical and none too effective exercise in mythicism assassination, nothing to do with rational, let alone unbiased, scholarship. 3 (trans. [A] persecution of Christians by the emperor Nero in connection with the Great Fire of 64 seems improbable given the context of the relations between officials of the Roman state and Christians over the first century CE. They thought this might serve their purpose. My own take on how the myth later developed, to appear full-blown in the writings of Sulpicius Severus, sees it as a combination of both Roman and Christian thinking in regard to the Fire and the blame the Christians tendency. 57 (trans. Chapter VI.Continuation. Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysos. This could mean that Rome was also experiencing envy and there were those who wanted leadership roles out of envy. Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. Further, Tacituss friend Pliny also described Christians in the same terms (the same words), seeing them as a plague spreading throughout the countryside of his province. So we return to Tacituss contemporary, Suetonius, who wrote: Christians were afflicted with punishments, a type of men of a new and evil superstitio . Welcome to the season where the only song we sing for fourweeks isO Come, O Come, Emmanuel! Indeed, the degree of certainty in the Neronian persecution stands in almost inverse proportion to the quality and quantity of the data. Therefore it is likely that Tacitus attests the persecution of the Chrestien Jews noted by Suetonius, given that most classical scholars do not identify Chrestus with Christ. Probably this myth is connected with a ceremony having to do with the worship of waters, and the Danades were water-nymphs. At first (only) those persons who confessed were arrested, but then because they were pointed out (denounced) by those (i.e. hero concept in European and Jewish mythology, and his (apocalyptic?) In the Gospel of John there was a prophecy that Peter would meet an undesirable fate and it seemed appropriate that he should die by crucifixion as hadJesus. This cannot be true because of the many warnings of judgment for Christians (e.g., Gal. Christians were known by the label Christian. 1 Clem. The Roman satirist Juvenal, another contemporary, wrote in the same vein of the Jews. He also presented a circus entertainment and in the dress of a charioteer he either mixed with the crowd or stood in his own chariot. And then the women who had husbands celebrated ritual banquets and nightly vigils. Dirce Amphion and Zethus subject Dirce to the bull (from the House of the Vettii, Pompeii) Dirce ( / drsi /; Ancient Greek: , pronounced [drk], modern Greek [irci], meaning "double" or "cleft") was a queen of Thebes as the wife of Lycus in Greek mythology . The third or fourth bishop of Rome has been proposed, but there are numerous pseudepigraphical texts attached to his name and no certain provenience or date can be established for the text. His treatment, although unnecessarily prolix, argues quite powerfully against the widespread conviction that Chrestus is Christ. Do you even know who Danaids and Dircae are? https://www.rebuildingthefoundations.org/faith-and-works-story.html. Note what Arthur Drews said in The Roman Witneses; Tacitus in The Witnesses to the Historicity of Jesus:, Chicago, The Open Court Publishing Co. (c1912) , Finally, there is the complete silence of profane writers and the vagueness of the Christian writers on the matter; the latter only gradually come to make a definite statement of a general persecution of the Christians under Nero, whereas at first they make Nero put to death only Peter and Paul. He wrote of one of several episodes of people in the East gaining following by falsely claiming to be Nero returning to re-claim theempire. And given that the penalties imposed upon these Christians in the days of Nero were associated with a mishmash of other legal restrictions and not with the Fire, wecan accept that Suetonius knew nothing of Christians being singled out for dire punishment because of the Fire. In almost every history of the early Christian Church, the event is marked as a dramatic turning point in the relations between Christians and the imperial government. It is very unlikely that in 50s and 50sC.E. You can download the paper by clicking the button above. "The grace of repentance" brought by the blood of Christ changes all that. can be read possibly as Philinna according to Mauricius Schmidt in his annotations of Hyginus. Your email address will not be published. To these men who spent their lives in the practice of holiness, there is to be added a great multitude of the elect, who, having through envy endured many indignities and tortures, furnished. At the same time a Nero myth was maturingamong the lower classes. Finally, for those that do not know, copyright allows "fair use" of all written works. Dirke was originally the wife of King Lykos (Lycus) of Thebes who, as punishment for the mistreatment of her niece Antiope, was tied to a wild bull and torn limb from limb. The few remnants of houses in the other seven were reduced to stripped and half-burned ruins. (I imagine the google search in . ", Nancy Fraser- June 2019 (personal email), "Many thanks for this post, and for the quality of your blog. Lactantius wrote accounts of the wrongful persecutions of Christians by Roman rulers yet he omits any mention of a fire in the time of Nero. The result is a few phrases in a single passage testifying to the Neronian persecution of Christians because of the fire of Rome and it is constructed fromanachronisms. You cannot have grace without repentance and faith. Let us look steadfastly to the blood of Christ, and see how precious that blood is to God, which, having been shed for our salvation, has set the grace of repentance before the whole world. What seems to make the idea so compelling and impossible to dismiss is that it is based on a high quality historical source of apparently unimpeachable fidelity, the Annales of the historian Tacitus. When she was with child, and her father threatened her, she ran away to Epopeus at Sikyon (Sicyon) and was married to him. 151168. They indeed killed their bridegrooms and buried their heads in Lerma, a region with lakes in southern Argos. It is used in the Roman Office of Readings for the liturgical memorial of the First Martyrs of the Church of Rome on June 30. 5 (trans. . It is hard to believe that Lactantius was wholly unaware of Tacitus. The fears and loathing were all set in the late first and early second century among these literary elite. These things, beloved, we write unto you, not merely to admonish you of your duty, but also to remind ourselves. The myth says that Danaus had fifty daughters, known as the Danaides, from four different women, while Aegyptus had fifty sons. At first those who confessed were taken away for punishment; subsequently others who were denounced by others were rounded up. Shaw accepts the high likelihood that rumours about who was responsible for the fire were rife. I know of no other site which offers a wide range of topics related to careful critical analysis of historically and scripturally related issues. I really should have included chapter 6 with chapters 3-5 because it is just a continuation. to remind ourselves.". It is easy to miss the fullness of it. With its atrium, its choir enclosed by a wall, its ambos, it is the most perfect model of an early basilica in Rome, though it was built as late as the first years of the twelfth century by Paschal II, after the destruction of this portion of the city by the Normans under Robert Guiscard. I once attempted to engage him in a discussion on Acts but was rebuffed as if I was a tool of Satan out to destroy Christianity because I questioned his assumptions even though I did so from the perspective of another relatively conservative scholar. Slingerlands own proposal for the identity of Chrestus is imaginative and novel. Three were burned to the ground. But the following passage speaks of Paul: Let us set before our eyes the illustrious apostles. Candida Moss has established the Christian penchant for claiming imaginary persecutions and per the Great Fire of Rome 64 CE and persecution of Christians, the thinness of the evidence on all aspects of it is quite striking (Shaw, 2015). Maybe this was because he loathed Christians too much to mention them at all anywhere in his work. The two brothers had regular rivalries over their kingdoms and where trying one to get the other's land. It is noteworthy that Poggio Bracciolini* seems by some lucky chance to have discovered and read this manuscript (work quoted, p. 225). Eusebius, Hist. They first made a stop in Rhodes, where they founded Lindos town and built a temple to goddess Athena Lindia. Wilson) (Greek rhetorician C2nd to 3rd A.D.) : Pseudo-Hyginus, Fabulae 7 (trans. Rouse) (Greek epic C5th A.D.) . "'As I live, saith the Lord, I desire not the death of the sinner, but rather his repentance' [Ezek. The Death of Peter and Paul. This post is going straight to the March 2016 Biblical Studies Carnival. "Dirke (Dirce) danced, spouting her whirling waters along with her father Ismenos (Ismenus).". Tom Berenger, It seems to me that being psycho-analysed is essentially a process where one is forced back into infantilism and then rescued from it by crystallising what one learns into a sort of intellectual primitivism-one is forced back into myth, and folk lore and everything that belongs to the savage or undeveloped stages of society. So, please continue to delve deeply and share this intellectual sustenance with your grateful readers. She felt pity for her husband, Lynceus, and spared his life. Christians were linked to those who were punished after the Great Fire.. Danaus soon understood the plan of his brother and was not willing to surrender his beautiful daughters to his nasty nephews. Chapter 6: Envy (Continued) This chapter just gives more examples of martyrdom and persecution and points out the basis of persecution is envy. Moreover, Shaw ignores the effect of certain writings by Christians later than Tacitus who not only show ignorance, they present a picture which has to rule out any Neronian pogrom. . Good job. Dirce was tied to the horns of a bull and then dragged to death." 6:2 By reason of jealousy women being persecuted, after that they had suffered cruel and unholy insults as Danaids and Dircae, safely reached the goal in the race of faith, and received a noble reward, feeble though they were in body. I will gloss over the details of Shawsarguments for the above and move on to the account by the Roman historian Tacitus of Neros persecution of the Christians in the wake of the Great Fire ofRome in 64 C.E. Through envy, those women, the Danaids and Dircae, being persecuted, after they had suffered terrible and unspeakable torments, finished the course of their faith with stedfastness, and though weak in body, received a noble reward. The historians qualities of veracity and accuracy, within the tolerable limits of the sources available to him, are not generally open to serious question. Danaus' brother Aegyptus had fifty children as well; in his case, all of them were male. The lack of connection is all the more striking since Lactantius was well aware of the tradition that Nero was a persecutor of Christians and of the rumours that Nero was going to return to earth, in some form, to renew the persecution. Before the wedding, he presented each of his daughters a dagger and instructed them to kill their husbands in their wedding night. "I still wonder at all the material you turn out for Vridar. To get rid of the rumour, Nero found and provided the defendants, and he afflicted with the most refined punishments those persons whom, hated for their shameful acts, Christians were afflicted with punishments, a type of men of a new and evil, What seems to have happened under Claudius and then again under Nero is the temporary banishment of some Jewish sectarians from the city of Rome, but not, in any event, persons who would logically have been labelled at the time as a new and evil, At the time, and indeed up to the decades after 100 C.E., among Roman writers, including Tacitus, it was the Jews rather than the Christians whose beliefs and practices were being labelled a. As such, he functioned as a personal attendant (amanuensis) of the Pope, writing letters at his behest and dictation, with no formal registration of the briefs, but merely preserving copies., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poggio_Bracciolini. The Danaids - or the Danaides; also called Belides after their grandfather - were the fifty daughters of Danaus, one of the two twin sons of king Belus of Egypt and the Naiad Anchinoe. All references to "writings from the apostles' churches" or "early Christian writings" on this site can be read at EarlyChristianWritings.com or Christian Classic Ethereal Library, as well as other web sites. . The intelligent Aegyptus wanted to get his sons married to the Danaides. Through envy, those women, the Danaids and Dirc, being persecuted, after they had suffered terrible and unspeakable torments, finished the course of their faith with stedfastness, and though weak in body, received a noble reward. The video says that Nero, by law, had to act and burned a bunch of Christians at the stake. When the sons found out who their mother was, they put Dirce to death by bidning her to an untamed bull; by the kindness of Liber [Dionysos], whose votary she was, on Mount Cithaeron, a spring was formed from her body, which was called Dirce. When her time was approaching, by the will of Jove [Zeus] she escaped from her chains to Mount Cithaeron, and when birth was imminent and she dsought for a place to bear her child, pain compelled her to give birth at the very crossroads. Dionysos afterwards transformed her into the spring for she had been a devoted follower of the god. Similar terminology is used in the New Testament. Those who have expressed even modest scepticism about the historicity of the one explicit passage in the historian Tacitus that attests to the executions have been voces clamantium in deserto. There were no crucifixions, for example. Excavations revealed that the medieval Church, built in the 12th century, actually was built on top of a 4th century Church which was in turn built over a house church going back to the first century. We all know the problem with this promise. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. never happened. Aldrich) (Greek mythographer C2nd A.D.) : Callimachus, Hymn 4 to Delos 75 ff (trans. The spring called Dirke (Dirce), running parallel to the Ismenos (Ismenus) and the walls themselves, which had always previously had clear and pure water, was suddenly and unexpectedly filled with blood. Dirke was originally the wife of King Lykos (Lycus) of Thebes who, as punishment for the mistreatment of her niece Antiope, was tied to a wild bull and torn limb from limb. Filed under: Ancient Literature, Historical Methods and Historiography, History and Biography
This document is the earliest Christian writing besides the New Testament documents. See back issues. Danaus built a ship with fifty oars and fled to Greece with his fifty daughters. Often enough punishments that in some way mimicked the crime were imposed. . A complete bibliography of the translations quoted on this page. And to those who were dying mockeries were added. 2:12). According to the footnote in The Ante-Nicene Fathers, they are either two unknown women or the phrase was possible added later. The danger they presented to society meant that they could be punished for being a Christian. But not to dwell upon ancient examples, let us come to the most recent spiritual heroes. In Greek mythology, the Danades (/dne.diz/; Greek: ), also Danaides or Danaids, were the fifty daughters of Danaus. Grant) (Roman mythographer C2nd A.D.) : We must not forget what a close connection there is between this narrative and the whole of Christian history, and what interest religious education and the Church have in preventing any doubt from being cast on it.. Ill try to offer something more substantial than 'Thank you' in response at some point, but I didnt want to wait . Suetonius makes no connection here with the Fire. Journal of Roman Studies, 105, pp 73-100 doi:10.1017/S0075435815000982. Tacitussincerely thought he had, in the late 110s and early 120s, evidence that a new sect known as Christians had been accused of being responsible for starting the fire, and that they were punished by Nero in order to deflect suspicions directed at himself. Author: Nicolas Roeg. Bowersock, somewhat chagrined, admits to being taken aback by Shaws carefully reasoned case that such an established tradition could suddenly be undercut, revealing cracks in an edifice we thought we knew well.. Online version at the Perseus Digital Library. ", "Thanks for your very elaborate review! Christians and Jews by the Fourth Century. Theoi Project Copyright 2000 - 2017 Aaron J. Atsma, Netherlands & New Zealand, (Callimachus Hymn to Delos, Nonnus Dionysiaca 44.10). No specifically identifiable author can be fixed for these letters. 10 ff (trans. The following two tabs change content below. The trope of the jealous spouse delating his wife to Roman authorities inthe city of Rome is also found in the writings of Justin Martyr who was probably writing in the mid-second century. Recall Plinys second century letter to the emperor Trajan confessing that he had little idea on how to judge the Christians who were being brought before him. The names of the Danades was complete but with new entries and some alteration in the spellings. 2:5). The myth says that, when they died, they Danaides were forced to a torment for eternity. In his review of books relating to Roman history, Inside the Emperors Clothes (Dec. 17), G. W. Bowersock makes mention of the recent article by Prof. Brent Shaw (The Myth of the Neronian Persecution) who calls into question the historical actuality of the tradition presented by Tacitus about a vast and cruel slaughter of Christians by the emperor Nero, accused of being responsible for the Great Fire in Rome in 64 CE. He is expressing the knowledge and judgments of his own time. The third is the special interest of the Roman Church in the death of the two chief apostles, Peter and Paul, at Rome. Lykos marched against Sikyon, subdued it, slew Epopeus, and led Antiope away captive. Let us attend to what is good, pleasing, and acceptable in the sight of Him who formed us. The forty-nine brides who killed their husband were punished for their crime. The Law of Moses could not deliver from sin or give the power to overcome it, but "what the Law could not do, God did by sending his Son" (Rom. Then the author of the letters of Seneca to Paul enlarged the legend in its primitive form, brought it into agreement with the ideas of this time, and gave it a political turn. Just to count the grand houses, the apartment blocks, and the temples that had been destroyed would be very difficult. It seems as if official science is here again, as in so many other cases, under the dominion of a long-continued suggestion, in taking the narrative of Tacitus to be genuine without further examination. In the classical tradition, they came to represent the futility of a repetitive task that can never be completed (see also Sisyphus and Ocnus). 5-6 "The Martyrdom of St. Paul and Condemnation of St. Peter" by Giovani Caraglio "There is a river called Dirke (Dirce) [near Thebes] after the wife of Lykos (Lycus). I do need to touch on the two women Clement lists, "the Danaids and Dircae." Slingerland, Howard Dixon (1997). Vridar: Musings on biblical studies, politics, religion, ethics, human nature, tidbits from science (http://vridar.org/) by Neil Godfrey", -- Klaas Spronk, - Bibliotheca Orientalis LXXI, 3/4 (2014). Furthermore, the routine fashion in which Pliny phrases his ignorance presumes that the emperor himself did not expect Pliny or any other high-ranking Roman to possess such obvious knowledge of the Christians. It is best dismissed from serious consideration of this problem as yet another one of the parasitic texts that have come to be attached to the fire and the first persecution under Nero in the assiduous hunt for any possible evidence that might strengthen the general argument. If Tacitus is the only source that connects Christians, their persecution, and the fire, we might usefully ask: what do other sources say about this same matter? Some time Id like to set out all the points of the various arguments Dohertys, Carriers, Shaws, (and Drews and others) and (preferably in collaboration with others) apply them all to a Bayesian analysis. This made the Christians infamous throughout Rome where they hadnt been known of before. Shaws article is valuable for casting such doubt on a supposedly key Christian martyr tradition, but his particular case is seriously flawed. Other references not currently quoted here: Euripides Bacchae 519, Euripides Heracles 27, Propertius 3.16.13. It is worth noting that Tacitus Annals 15 derives from a single manuscript, found in the derives from a single manuscript found in a monastery at Monte Cassino in the 13 or 14th century, that also found its way into the hands of Poggio Bracciolini. God has always forgiven those who repent (Ps. The reason for Nero attacking the Christians (including the deaths of Peter and Paul), according to Lactantius, was the same as we read of in Plinys correspondence: the pagan cults were being abandoned because of the success of Christian preaching. 18:20-30). He nevertheless does not subscribe to the historians account of Neros reign. I refer to your site frequently as yet more names and publications pop up requiring an academic critique and helpful recommendations for book purchases. The first part of the article explores the context in which these designations appear. .The Sybilline Oracles believed the legend that Nerowas a Once and Future Kinga villain in the West but a hero in the Eastwho would one day return at the head of the Parthian armies to destroy the Roman Empire. How, then, Shaw asks, was this new information about the Christians circulating among the governing officials at the time? Contents 1 Family 2 Mythology 3 In Roman culture 4 Notes 5 References . They had been denounced as Christians by their jealous husbands. Guided by the gods and not intending to cause a war between them, he decided to give his kingdom to his brother and leave the country in search for another life. Let us take the noble examples furnished in our own generation. ", "Here I give an admittedly subjective short list, in random order, of useful, high level and regularly updated weblogs on the study of the Old Testament . Several other martyrs. (p. 231), Allen, N.P.L. Tertullian was born the son of a Roman Centurion in Carthage around 150 AD. What is missing in the punishments described, however, is anything suggesting a Christian association. Through jealousy women were made to appear as Danaids and Dircae, suffering terrible and unholy indignities; they finished the race of faith unshaken and received a noble reward, weak in the body though they were. ", Aelian, Historical Miscellany 12. Abstract The purpose of the current article is to address a question to which scholars devoted considerable thought: the identity of the Christian women whom Clement of Rome called Danads and Dircae in his First Epistle to the Corinthians. Online version at the Topos Text Project. At the time, and indeed up to the decades after 100 C.E., among Roman writers, including Tacitus, it was the Jews rather than the Christians whose beliefs and practices were being labelled a superstitio, albeit not a novel one. The Greek text in 6.2 is not without its complications, but it is entirely possible that the reference to the Danaids, alluding to how the daughters of Danas were given as prizes to the winners of a race, may be an indication of how some Christian women endured public rape before their executions. 25. Dirke was originally the wife of King Lykos (Lycus) of Thebes who, as punishment for the mistreatment of her niece Antiope, was tied to a wild bull and torn limb from limb. Even in the New Testament, we are told that at the judgment those who patiently to do good will be rewarded in eternal life (Rom. He cites Richard Carriers 2014 article,The prospect of a Christian interpolation in Tacitus, Annals15.44, in VigiliaeChristianae 68, 26483 as a recent example and source for many of the earlier studies. Because the water was always leaking, they would forever try to fill the tub. Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labors and when he had at length suffered martyrdom, departed to the place of glory due to him. He indulged in all the trappings of his day, including the pastime of watching gladiatorial combat and games where criminals were tortured or eaten alive by wild animals. I think, though, that Clement is simply saying that battle for holiness and a pure church is a battle every church must continue in. But how could the legend arise that Nero was the first to persecute the Christians? You can return Home, go to the index of commentaries, or go to my categorized index of artices. DIRKE (Dirce) was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirke near Thebes in Boiotia (central Greece). So much for the late legend of Peter being crucified, let alone crucified upside down. They would be released from this punishment, only if the basin was full of water. The gaps are striking lacunae in the knowledge of a senator from Italy, frequently resident in or near the imperial capital, who was well informed on these matters, if in fact Christians had been found guilty of a monstrous crime against the Roman state in the mid-60s. writes eloquently about the Great Fire but whispers not a word about Christians in connection with it. Covered with the hides of wild animals they perished by being torn to pieces by dogs or, fixed to stakes (or, crosses) they were set afire in the darkening evening as a form of night lighting. . Up until the time of Tacitus this expression had been used of an ethnic group to refer to the Jews. Her waters were sacred to the god Dionysos. Irving, TX 75062 The Christians were expecting the end of the world by fire and they thought this might be it. 64 (2): 231242. Enjoy reading and share 5 famous quotes about Danaides And Dircae with everyone. A shepherd who is a father figure to the boys after helping to raise them convinces them of the truth that Antiope is their real mother. ", "I want to say here that this site is so resourceful and highly on top of the most modern scholarship in the areas discussed here. It advocated a racially integrated German nation at the heart of a central European customs union, the basis of a united states of Europe. Grant) (Roman mythographer C2nd A.D.) : Nonnus, Dionysiaca 44. Having no other option, he consented for the wedding and organized a low-profile wedding party. pp. Magda Szab's 1964 novel, A Danaida (The Danaid), is about a woman who lives selfishly for two-thirds of her life without realizing that even she can change the course of history. It might help to read my story of discovering the true purpose of the atonement at https://www.rebuildingthefoundations.org/faith-and-works-story.html in the Scriptures and the early fathers. The Jews from Jerusalem marveled at the precious gift given to the Gentiles, Cornelius being the first, by saying, "So God has granted repentance to life to the Gentiles as well" (Acts 11:18). The myth of Danaides is the story of fifty women who commit a horrible wrongdoing: guided by their father, they all kill their husbands on their wedding night! Think about thismany apologists are claiming the disciples and early followers were killed for their belief, and the Bishop of Rome, in either 65 or 95 CE, could only come up with Peter, Paul, Danaids and Dircae. In fact, Godfrey is extremely well read and his librarian skills have brought many important academic works to my attention. As Peter wrote,"I think it is right, as long as I am in this tabernacle [this body], stir you up by reminding you" (2 Pet. The gods Athena and Hermes purified them at the command of Zeus. The myth of Danaides is the story of fifty women who commit a horrible wrongdoing: guided by their father, they all kill their husbands on their wedding night! Where to eat? Some accounts tell that their punishment in Tartarus was being forced to carry a jug to fill a bathtub (pithos) without a bottom (or with a leak) to wash their sins off. ISMENOS (Callimachus Hymn to Delos, Nonnus Dionysiaca 44.10), Pseudo-Apollodorus, Bibliotheca 3. . Deliberately to overlook and to ignore such a parallel with an earlier known tyrant whom Lactantius himself accepts persecuted Christians, and thereby to miss the opportunity to tie together the first and the last of the persecutors, is almost inexplicable unless he was unaware of the connection or had discounted it for some reason. Indeed, the Danaides were punished for this after their death with a horrible and eternal torment. ", Earl Doherty, November 2013 (personal email), "Note that I do not use the term amateur pejoratively. It is, however, very doubtful, in view of the silence of the other Christian authors who used Tacitus, if the manuscript of Tacitus which Sulpicius used contained the passage in question. Danaus agreed to the marriage of his daughters only after Aegyptus came to Argos with his fifty sons in order to protect the local population, the Argives, from any battles. For example, when Tacitus says that there arose a distaste towards Nero for his executions because they were perceived to be a concession to the emperors bestiality and not a contribution to the. ", "I find your blog most interesting and appreciate your ongoing effort to keep to the evidence for the issues discussed! He nevertheless does not subscribe to the historians account of Neros reign. lol) MY VIEWPOINT ON RACISM IS, Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. In Greek mythology, the Danades ( / dne.diz /; Greek: ), also Danaides or Danaids, were the fifty daughters of Danaus. Most evangelicals believe that Jesus died to pay for all our sins so that we will no longer be judged for what we do. Orosius interpretatio christiana rests on no evidence independent of Suetonius. Copyright 2023 Famous Quotes & Sayings. I dont know if they will print it, because it relates to a secondary subject within the review in question. 6:14). Danaus didn't want that his beautiful and prosperous Argos suffer because of a war. What seems to have happened under Claudius and then again under Nero is the temporary banishment of some Jewish sectarians from the city of Rome, but not, in any event, persons who would logically have been labelled at the time as a new and evil superstitio, words which were used only much later by Roman officials to label Christians. I dont always agree with them, but I respect their work. 51:16-17; Ezek. I reserve all rights, but I give permission to use this page in Bible studies or other FREE ways. And it will not do to save the Christian hypothesis by postulating Suetonius ignorance. Without doubt, Danaus brought her in front of the Argos court. ", Callimachus, Hymn 4 to Delos 75 ff (trans. smuggled the dramatic account of this persecution into the Annals of Tacitus, and thus secured the acceptance as historical fact of a purely imaginary story. Response to Christopher Jones: The Historicity of the Neronian Persecution. We are therefore strongly disposed to suspect that the passage (Annals, xv, 44) was transferred from Sulpicius to the text of Tacitus by the hand of a monastic copyist or forger, for the greater glory of God and in order to strengthen the truth of the Christian tradition by a pagan witness.[67]. Your clarity of expression, fair comments and personal insights are much valued. 2. Nouvelles Considerations, pp. It arose, says Hochart, under a threefold influence. I think it expands, and contributes to, the effort in honouring Thomas that we with Lukasz originally had in mind with this volume. The first is the apocalyptic idea, which saw in Nero the Antichrist, the embodiment of all evil, the terrible adversary of the Messiah and his followers. ISBN 1-905048-0-68. The late tales of the martyrdoms of Peter and Paul appear to have been expressions of what second century Christians wanted to believe. Looking forward to more segments. : Pausanias, Description of Greece 9. His views are at bottom mere apologetics, anyway as you yourself comment with respect to point 2. Nero was seen as a benefactor of the poor and common persons and a future restorer of a golden age. They were to marry the 50 sons of Danaus' twin brother Aegyptus, a mythical king of Egypt. Paul says that he went throughout the world preaching that the Gentiles should repent and turn to God, doing works suitable for repentance" (Acts 26:20). This is ingenious but highly speculative, as Slingerland himself concedes. Around the turn of the century, then, an identifiable group, disruptive to the social order and known as Christians, were coming to the notice of the ruling classes. Here is Shaws translation of the passage, beginning at the beginning: A disaster followed. DID TACITUS WRITE OF A NERONIAN PERSECUTION OF CHRISTIANS? Claud. available online @ http://dspace.nwu.ac.za/handle/10394/14213, Your email address will not be published. ", "Fantastic. . Argive ancestor For having been seduced by Zeus, Io, a native from Argos, was severely punished by the god's jealous wife Hera, who pursued her all over the world. It is very possible that this was the house of St. Clement himself. "We are struggling on the same arena, and the same conflict is assigned to both of us.". Nor does Acts 18:1-3 help the cause, for its reference to Jews expelled from Rome who joined Paul in Corinth does not suggest that they were Christians when they left Rome. The historian certainly knew the differencebetween governors who were praefecti and those who were procuratores, and elsewhere he notes the distinction. Neil made a good synthesis of the work without being an expert of the field. A technical comment regarding Clements Letter to the Corinthians: As far as I remember (also from Earl Dohertys texts), the expressions put to death (in most righteous pillars [of the Church] have been persecuted and put to death) and suffered martyrdom under the prefects do not correspond to the Greek text (which gives no indication of violent deaths). [13] At the Emperor Neros wish, the woman, like mythological Dirce, was tied to a wild bull and dragged around the arena.Clements Letter to the Corinthians. I find the point 2 particularly biased and apologetical: impliciter, he is winking at those who say that the Romans coined the term Christian because they were historicists: the Christians were followers of a historical human leader. Le chtiment des Danades is an essay by the French-Canadian author Henri Paul Jacquesthe applying the Freudian concept of psychoanalysis to the study of the punishment imposed on the Danades after they committed their crimes. Then, Danaus and his daughters reached Argos, the birthplace of his great-grand-mother, the Argian princess Io. Tacitus describes the Christians in the same way, as a plague or contagion, and likewise emanating from Judea. The Neronian persecution first appears full-blown in Sulpicius Severus, a Christian historian writing around 400 CE. In Jewish apocalyptic mythology Nero was depicted as a bestial figure, no doubt because the war that ended with the destruction of the Temple was commenced under his reign. Document Details : Title: 'Danades et Dircs' Subtitle: Sur 1 Cl 6,2 Author(s): KOZLOWSKI, Jan M. Journal: Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses Volume: 82 Issue: 4 Date: December 2006 Pages: 467-478 DOI: 10.2143/ETL.82.4.2018923 Abstract : The purpose of the current article is to address a question to which scholars devoted considerable thought: the identity of the Christian women whom . The connections were such that Tacitus had at his disposal, in either written or oral sources, what he believed to be credible and compelling grounds to accept the stories that linked the Christians, Nero, and the fire at Rome as elements of a true narrative. Mirbt, n.33. The presumed authenticity of Tacitus passage (Annals 15:44) has long been a key plank in the case for the existence of an historical Jesus, within the long but lately resurgent question (now popularly referred to as Jesus mythicism) as to whether Jesus actually existed or is a fictional/allegorical character. Some history is putty in the hands of this or that historian like the 1984 memory-holers. At this point Tacitus introduces the episode about the Christians. Nevertheless, it is evident that this catalogue has almost nothing in common with that of Pseudo-Apollodorus. Evidently two developments had taken place prior to his writing the Annales: These developments were arbitrary, matters of choice, and not inevitable. Through envy, those women, the Danaids 32 and Dirc, being persecuted . 232-241). I shall not attempt to suggest why Jews or Christians might have thought badly of this imperial Apollo, especially as in currently predominant fashion the former could never have done wrong and the latter can never do right; and trust also that this doesnt provoke a tedious academic Armageddon over the real identity of 666. Names with () symbol means corrupted entries but annotations from various editors were provided to rationalize their possible names. They should carry jugs of water and fill a basin. Required fields are marked *. He made a secret plan to get rid of Aegyptus and his sons for good. return to rescue his nation/people &c. This persists even in the bizarre sci-fi cult-fiction of the cryogenic Adolf in Antarctica. He certainly knew of the Great Fire. 142-72. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Witnesses_to_the_Historicity_of_Jesus/Part_2/Section_2. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. The paucity and weakness of the data, however, have not prevented acceptance of the historicity of this first persecution as an undisputed fact. Even later Roman historians do not reflect the myth, such as Suetonius and Cassius Dio, and Shaws suggested reasons for this are hardly adequate. Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer. suffered cruel and unholy insults as Danaids and Dircae, safely reached the goal in the race of faith, and received a noble reward, feeble though they were in body. This second group were singled out because others believed they had a general hatred for humankind. My I quote, without being accused of irrelevant trolling, from A.N. I call them amateurs only for the reason that they dont have, so far as I know, advanced degrees in the subject. Instead, the apostles and the early fathers understood that Jesus came to really take away sin. (I) Why does Clement quote so many texts of the Old Testament and only a few words . (Keeping it brief this time really? 3 (trans. The name of Christian was not applied so early as the identifier of this Jewish sect. 6:7-9). ", "Neil Godfrey and Tim Widowfield, who both write at Vridar . us with a most excellent example. Crossans Jesus and the Violence of Scripture (SPCK 2015), a passage re Nero, not because I support either of these writers in their views of HJ but because it rang a bell regarding the transmission of the (divine?) For example, when Tacitus says that there arose a distaste towards Nero for his executions because they were perceived to be a concession to the emperors bestiality and not a contribution to the utilitas publica of the state, he is surely echoing a dominant ideology not of the 60s but of his own age. Its the best! I know certain arguments in isolation do seem very persuasive, such as the forgery one. In a footnote Holmes explains the reference to Danaids and Dircae: "[I]n ancient mythology the daughters of Danaus were given as prizes to the winners of a race; thus it is likely that this is a reference to Christian women being raped prior to being martyred. DIRKE (Dirce) was the Naiad-nymph of the spring of Dirke near Thebes in Boiotia (central Greece). The Church of St. Clement is one of the most fascinating places in Rome. . Sheffield Phoenix Press. In the most common version of the myth, all but one of them killed their husbands on their wedding night, and are condemned to spend eternity carrying water in a sieve or perforated device. This first letter of Clement (a second letter was falsely attributed to him) was copied by the Corinthian Church and circulated all over the empire, rendering the very first papal encyclical. It was so highly regarded by the universal church that for several centuries the Church in Egypt and elsewhere regarded it as one of the New Testament scriptures. Nothing suggests Jesus Christ here. Myths that Nero would one-day return to overthrow his enemies had circulated. The two narrative lines look too similar to be independent of one another. Envy has alienated wives from their husbands, and changed that saying of our father Adam, "This is now bone of my . For all we know from the available evidence Peter died in the 50s, in Jerusalem, peacefully in his sleep. Mair) (Greek poet C3rd B.C.) Books and publications are covered with a range of perspectives with attempts at fair and accurate representation of others arguments and content (where there are occasional and inevitable missteps on that I notice Neil making corrections and apologies where warranted, which wins points with me). The third or fourth bishop of Rome has been proposed, but there are numerous pseudepigraphical texts attached to his name and no certain provenience or date can be established for the text. Dirce who treats Antiope cruelly throughout her life, instructs the twins to kill their mother. But I have often been impressed with their grasp of logic and analysis of scholarship. Overlooked or downplayed in the longstanding debate over the Tacitus passage has been the stark fact that no Christian commentator for over three centuries ever refers to a general anti-Christian pogrom by Nero (beyond the legendary executions of Peter and Paul, which are never linked to the fire). I realized that I hadnt added your blog to our blogroll. Ian Kershaw, What a great privilege it is to be here Bonnie L. Oscarson, My mother, sister and I watched through the windows as my father gambled. Danaides And Dircae Quotes & Sayings Enjoy reading and share 5 famous quotes about Danaides And Dircaewith everyone. Of course, we can conclude that we all do. Lynceus, the only survivor of the fifty sons of Aegyptus, later killed Danaus to revenge for his brothers. 20:28). The rank was true of Tacitus own time, but not of Pilatus own when praefectus was the title held by the governor of Judaea. Journal of Greco-Roman Christianity and Judaism (JGRChJ). Thus was he removed from the world, and went into the holy place, having proved himself a striking example of patience. It is hard to believe that Lactantius was wholly unaware of Tacitus. This oversight has been corrected. He then returns to the events of Neros time. Abstract of a recently published article by Princeton University Professor of Classics, Brent D. Shaw: Brent D. Shaw (2015). This may be a new way of thinking for a lot of you. Unpublished Philosophiae Doctor thesis, Potchefstroom: North-West University. The problems here are almost overwhelming. 1:13). Afterwards, they remarried by choosing their mates in footraces (or their father bestowed them to the victors of the athletic contest[2]). And Dohertys point about the failure to reference Tacituss passage until very late, too Id like to assess it carefully against the alternative proposed by Shaw. (A white Muslim convert I knew well in Norwich once said to me, We dont make your distinction between fact and fiction!). Many points in the passage have been closely debated, but as a whole does it reflect reliable history? Who? In Monday Begins on Saturday, it is mentioned that the Danades had their case reviewed in modern times, and, due to mitigating circumstances (the marriage being forced), had their punishment changed to laying down and then immediately demolishing asphalt. The vague charges of incendiarism assumed a more definite form, and were associated with the character of Antichrist, which the Church was accustomed to ascribe to Nero on account of his supposed diabolical cruelty. . Greeka? Tacitus and Suetonius speak elsewhere of the Jews as representinga pernicious religion, of expulsions of Jews from Rome, of corrupt practices coming from the east, including Judea. Tacitus himself was well aware of these developments. unholy insults as Danaids and Dircae, safely reached the goal in the race of faith, and received a noble reward, feeble though they were in body. Clement, writing for the church of Rome, gives a humble beginning to his discussion on repentance.
Si Jamais J'oublie Partition Chorale,
Town Of Milbridge, Maine Tax Maps,
Famous Examples Of Perjury,
Raley's Employee Handbook,
Dorothy Virginia Gumm,
Metro Service Attendant Job Description,
Https Allegisgroup Kronos Net Wfc Navigator Logon,
Minecraft Crash Report Analyzer,
What Are The Difference Between Entrepreneurship And Employment Brainly,
Bartender Jobs Nyc Craigslist,
Science Hill Student Death February 2022,